Referendum: Creation of the Soybooru Senate

433 replies·6107 views·
Pinned
User avatar
muscular_engineer

Inventor of the Mineral Inspecteur Soyjak

2 days ago#1290130
The current referendum system closely resembles direct democracy (the ancient Greek "demokratos"), which generally requires a highly informed and active voting population which understands the implications and second order effects of their decisions.

As the referendum process has shown, many Soybooru users lack this wisdom, and often shoot themselves in the foot with well-intentioned but rash, reactive, poorly-thought-out referendums which end up fucking themselves over in the long run.

Although the desire for user input in the site's administration is commendable, it should be filtered through a Senate which will deliberate on the consequences of such referendums and make a wise ruling.

Rule 15. The Soybooru Senate shall be created in accordance with the following sub-rules.
1. The Soybooru Senate shall consist of thrembo Senators, rounded up to 7 to prevent tied votes.
2. The Senate shall have the power to approve or deny referendums. It shall choose among itself by majority decision whether to approve or deny them. No referendum shall be passed without the approval of the Senate, regardless of the results of any popular vote attached therein.
3. Election: If the Senate lacks any number of members, they shall be elected as follows: The longest-serving Senator, or (if there are no Senators) an admin, shall make a forum post asking for senatorial candidates. Users may recommend themselves or others as candidates on their behalf. After a three-day period, a vote with each candidate listed as an individual choice shall be held. Senatorial election votes shall have options "Multiple Choice" and "Display Voters" enabled, with an expiration time of 72 hours. When the vote expires, vacant Senate seats shall be filled by candidates in order from most votes to least until all vacant seats are filled.
In the event two or more users are tied with the most votes for any Senate seat, a runoff vote shall be held for this seat containing only those users as candidates, but otherwise conducted in the same manner as other Senatorial elections.
4. Recall: Individual Senators can be recalled at any point, for any reason, by a forum post demanding such action and containing a vote of at least 100 votes with 75% or greater "yes". Recall votes shall be posted in the same manner as referendums but with the option "Display Voters" enabled. If a recall vote is successful, the recalled Senator shall immediately cease their senatorial duties and be removed from the Senate. The Senate shall not veto any Senatorial recall.

Loading poll...
/ 22
User avatar
Olgol

Enemy of the fatherless nation (Shroom)

2 days ago#1290143·
Woah this sounds awesome
User avatar
Jeff

Test 6.27.2026 17:38:15

2 days ago#1290152·
more drama
User avatar
KILLTRANNIES

poopwaffen

2 days ago#1290162
Okay.
User avatar
sulfurald

A vote for me is a vote for (You!) This message is paid for by RUPAC

2 days ago#1290163
/dem/
User avatar
KILLTRANNIES

poopwaffen

2 days ago#1290168
@muscular_engineer ill vote yes if you make me part of the senate
User avatar
sulfurald

A vote for me is a vote for (You!) This message is paid for by RUPAC

2 days ago#1290183
i'm the only person so far to pass one of these
User avatar
muscular_engineer

Inventor of the Mineral Inspecteur Soyjak

2 days ago#1290187
KILLTRANNIES
@muscular_engineer ill vote yes if you make me part of the senate
I don't get to pick that, the first senators would be selected via an election
User avatar
babababababababa

Muhammad Ali, or, whatever

2 days ago#1290194
Sounds like a fun idea, leads to more shitflinging
User avatar
Pseudo

Keep calm and carry on.

2 days ago#1290196
W larps
User avatar
KILLTRANNIES

poopwaffen

2 days ago#1290199
muscular_engineer
KILLTRANNIES
Show quoted text
@muscular_engineer ill vote yes if you make me part of the senate
I don't get to pick that, the first senators would be selected via an election
Vote for me in the election
User avatar
sulfurald

A vote for me is a vote for (You!) This message is paid for by RUPAC

2 days ago#1290201
babababababababa
Sounds like a fun idea, leads to more shitflinging
top text
bottom text
User avatar
sulfurald

A vote for me is a vote for (You!) This message is paid for by RUPAC

2 days ago#1290209·
random nophono soytubers are going to win this instantly
User avatar
H3K

Status Pending Approval

2 days ago#1290214
Sounds like an interesting concept.
User avatar
supersagecoal

or something

2 days ago#1290221
sulfurald
random nophono soytubers are going to win this instantly
Post #250439
User avatar
Snophono

Terminal SNCA

2 days ago#1290229
Soymocracy?
User avatar
Dove

Currently playing: Dave the Diver

2 days ago#1290234
I would vote yes if moderators were granted automatic senate seats (incumbent senators)
User avatar
Govnoje

Anti-Defamation League Chairman

2 days ago#1290239
Dove
I would vote yes if moderators were granted automatic senate seats (incumbent senators)
Let the public have some power
User avatar
Randals_Strongest_Warrior

The world has turned and left me here

2 days ago#1290242
/dem2/ or something :unc:
User avatar
Marigold

We'll make the world a garden. We'll only scatter seeds

2 days ago#1290245
Wait but aren't you trying to achieve this goal through the same system you seem to criticize?
Post #176560
/ 22
Log in to reply to this thread.