@Chud<\/a>:
>Composed by Imam Muhammad al-Bukhari<\/span>
Composed after 222 years of death of Prophet Muhammad (s).
Number of hadiths collected by Imam Bukhari = 600,000 hadiths.
Number of hadiths rejected by Imam Bukhari = 592,725 hadiths.
Number of hadiths selected by Imam Bukhari = 7,275 hadiths.
Hadiths rejected by assumptions = 99%
Hadiths accepted by assumptions = 1%
Imam Bukhari rejected 99 % of what he collected and called it pure lies and fabrication and accepted only 1 %.
Was he infallible like messengers ? No
Was he divinely guided by Allah in his work? No
So what is his criterion of assuming a hadith right or wrong ?

Answer - Personal assumptions.
why personal assumptions?
Because,
There was no public library of hadiths as hadiths were burned and banned at the time of four caliphs and was not recorded till first 250 years after Prophet's departing of world. (why that's another long answer)
There was no Internet database like Google drive at that time.
(mainly.....)
Imam Bukhari assumes according to him which narrators are not liars and which hadith can be considered authentic and which narrators are liars and hadith is false.
Now,
(Just calculate the mathematical and rational probability of Imam Bukhari of being wrong in some of hadiths among that 1% too)
and what authority he is of Islam?

(I have absolutely no idea how anyone can assume who is liar and who is not from first narrator in the time of Prophet Muhammad who existed 250 years ago to last narrator who was alive at the time of Bukhari)

(I can't even tell you today while living in world of modern information age that a person who lived in 1817 is liar or truthful lest the chain of narrators from 1817 to 2017 | can you?)

Tags

Comments(89)