News & Politics

"Stalin raped a 13-year-old girl" debunked

This claim is apocryphal, and the main source of its propagation is Simon Sebag Montefiore, author of the pop history book The Court of the Red Tsar and other biographical works about Stalin.
The main aim of pop history is to create an engaging narrative, which often involves embellishing or cherry-picking details. Several copies of the book I've found omit the story entirely.
Most historians and academics who have studied Stalin do not consider the story to be credible. There are no primary sources in Soviet archives to corroborate this claim, either.
Even disregarding the apocryphal nature of the claim, it doesn't stand up to scrutiny. Stalin left the village nearly 13 months before the child was born, having arrived in the town of Kureika, where Lidiya lived, in mid-March 1914. He could not have fathered a child with Perepryginova in 1913 or 1914, since he moved in with the Pereprygin family in mid-May 1914.
>but there was a DNA test confirming it!
This originates from the Siberian Times, a tabloid news source. Western tabloids parroted the article, where it spread to the west.
Several other articles by the Siberian Times include:
Beware: Brown bear armed with two guns on the loose in Siberian Region
Woman pulls two trams full of passengers weighing 36 tons - in minus 20 cold
The Siberian Times was shut down, but here's an article corroborating the above articles
https://mashable.com/article/siberian-times-best-of
wordswordswords dnr
DNR
When will you debunk non-giant-spoon believers
Now debunk stalin being a massive nigger ass jew who betrayed all the old bolsheviks
muscular_engineer↗
Now debunk stalin being a massive nigger ass jew who betrayed all the old bolsheviks
Jew vs jews
White army won because they arent leftie tankie snowflake
pantokrator↗
muscular_engineer↗
Show quoted text
Now debunk stalin being a massive nigger ass jew who betrayed all the old bolsheviks
Jew vs jews
There are jews and there are jews
Ignore this post, I posted it on a wrong thread
So this nigga debunked something by not debunking it. But it doesn't make any sense because actual people who were close to Stalin do remember him having a relationship with that girl. Even Stalin's table talks and his biography even proved this.
eh still don't like the guy
stalin advocated state atheism. he would never have done anything christian like that.
Right-wingers will repeat debunked information like this and then say Epstein had aura.
What if stalin had a trans bbc
Som3phono↗
What if stalin had a trans bbc
he had
:snca:
"Ur argument wrong because source tendencious. Why? I cherry picked the source" aaaah argument
Shit not even norhino cares fan about
All communists are childphiles
AdolfTrumpson↗
So this nigga debunked something by not debunking it. But it doesn't make any sense because actual people who were close to Stalin do remember him having a relationship with that girl. Even Stalin's table talks and his biography even proved this.
Who? What biography?
Log in to reply to this thread.